ISA England Section - Technical Articles

Monitoring or Control & Safety ? 

Not all Temperature measurement points were created equal 

The Author

 

Jose M. Rivera joined Fisher-Rosemount in 1994. He holds an Electrical Engineering degree from the University of Costa Rica, as well as a Masters in Business Administration (MBA) from Northwestern University in Illinois, USA. He is currently based out of Karlstein (Germany)  the location of Rosemount Temperature GmbH and functions as Director, Temperature Solutions – Europe, Middle East and Africa.  He worked the first year of his European assignment out of the Bognor Regis (England).  Prior to that he worked as a product and sales manager in Minneapolis, and in St. Louis (USA) and as a sales and design engineer in San Jose (Costa Rica).

 

Temperature is by far the most measured variable in a typical industrial plant. The importance of temperature for most processes, as well its affordability, explain this.  There are two very distinct segments when it comes to temperature measurements: Monitoring and Control & Safety. As will be presented, technology is having a significant impact on both segments.

 

Monitoring

 

A significant portion (60-70%) of the temperature points falls in the monitoring segment. This means that the measurement is used as a supporting reading to the more critical control variable.  Because of its supporting or secondary role, accuracy is not the main concern for these points; reliability, repeatability and affordability are.

 

In the past monitoring points were wired directly to the control room without the benefit of a transmitter.  This practice is quickly disappearing because of the inherent technical problems of  “wire-direct”, the higher wiring costs (particularly in the case of thermocouples), and the affordability of temperature transmitters.

 

New technologies are having a significant impact on temperature transmitters. For Monitoring applications the use of open digital protocols (e.g. Foundation Fieldbus) allow significant wire cost savings, as multiple transmitter readings can be channeled through the same pair of wires. In addition, multiple sensor input transmitters extend this advantage even further. Temperature transmitters with eight inputs, communicating via a single pair of wires are a reality today. These multi-sensor transmitters can at the same time be configured to share the same pair of wires, reducing the wiring costs even further.

 

Control & Safety

 

The rest of the temperature points (30-40%) fall in the control & safety segment. For control loops accuracy, stability, reliability, and repeatability are the key drivers.  A process managed tightly has enormous financial benefits.  Affordability (cost) plays a secondary role, as a top performing transmitter will more than pay for itself. In the case of safety loops, the transmitter is left with the responsibility of triggering the installation in case of an emergency. A poorly performing transmitter could trigger the plant unnecessarily, at a large expense. Even if multiple transmitters are used for the same measurement point to provide redundancy, these loops deserve the best transmitters available on the market. . For safety loops reliability, and repeatability are the key drivers

 

 

New technology is having an impact on the Control & Safety side as well. Digital protocols have opened up the full transmitter intelligence to the users. This means that the advanced transmitters can diagnose not only themselves, but also the process, through advanced signal processing algorithms. Transmitters currently on the market can perform a temperature measurement on a dual element sensor. In  the case of the breakdown of one of the two elements, the transmitter will transition to the surviving element, without any disruption. The condition is then reported to let the personnel schedule the replacement at a convenient time. The transmitter can also tell when its sensors have fallen outside of the acceptable accuracy range and that they need replacement. Transmitters available today and using the Foundation Fieldbus protocol can act as the primary or secondary controllers as well.

 

In summary, Temperature is a very common measurement variable. It is important to consider the use the measurement will have and base the equipment selection accordingly. Technology is having a significant impact in the way we measure Temperature today, both in Monitoring as well in Control & Safety loops.